1803
A Friday forenoon in Aippasi
On the forenoon of Friday, 21 October 1803, in the Tamil month of Aippasi of the year 979, a man named Savarimuthu Pillai, who had come from Tirunelveli to see Mr Bilderbeck, a European settled in the village, went into the church to pray. The statue of Our Lady of the Assumption stood above the altar in a recess closed by a double door, and that morning both its leaves were open. As he knelt, a thin transparent cloud gathered behind her and wrapped her round. Her eyes lifted toward heaven and filled, and the tears ran down her cheeks; her face turned sorrowful; and her folded hands parted and stretched out until they touched the walls of the recess. And every other statue on the altar, the record says, “expressed compassion and mourning”. “I am the subject of an illusion,” he thought. He looked again, harder, and it had not stopped.
In English
“Saveri-Mouttou Pillai, son of Satiavasagam Pillai, had come from Tirunelveli to see Monsieur Bilderbeck, a European who lived at Vadakencoulam. Saveri-Mouttou was a fervent Christian; about eleven in the morning he went to the church to make his devotions. The statue of the Blessed Virgin, placed above the altar, was in a niche with a double door that could be opened or closed at will. At that moment the two leaves were open…”
What this source establishes
The earliest printed witness, a Jesuit of this mission (Lettres de Gemert, 1905), nine years before Besse. He sets down the whole scene: Saveri-Mouttou Pillai, son of Satiavasagam Pillai, come from Tirunelveli to see Monsieur Bilderbeck; the statue in a niche with a double door, both leaves open that morning; the cloud, the tears, the outstretched hands. He also, honestly, records that the Goa priest was absent and no ecclesiastical document approving it exists.